Score: 9

"I played for hours..."

submission: Besieged

date: July 1, 2008

As a big fan of Tower Defense games, this one caught my interest. There were so many good things that it will be easier to just name what I want better/fixed

1. Upgrades need to be purchasable, either a store or during the game
2. NO PAUSE BUTTON!? please, that makes this so long and hard and kinda sad
3. More weapons, Arch, Ballista, Sapper, and Cannon are sweet. Add a few more expensive ones like: Trebuchet and catapult. You could even add your own men to go out and fight!!
4. and last thing I REALLY REALLY REALLLLY WANTED: more levels :)

Game was great, 5/5 8.5 (so 9)/10.

Score: 4

"too easy"

submission: The Pirate Collab

date: June 29, 2008

you just have to hold the down arrow down and only jump for barrels. too simple, 4/10

Fix that 'cheat' and it'll be better. And 9 authors to make this? I hope theres more than the eye can see, because I'm not impressed...

Score: 5

"Eh,"

submission: Happy Cat

date: June 10, 2008

5/10

First Star: Creative artistic drawing
Second Star: Detailed animation
Third Star: Simple message
Fourth Star: Wasn't BORING
Fifth Star: Short, so less painful.

Why you only got 5: Unoriginal idea. The ending wasn't that spectacular. But most of all, the sound effects were way over the top and annoying. I turned down my sound just so I didn't stop watching the movie. It may sound harsh, but I'm sure I'm not the only viewer who was bothered by your sounds.

Rework and show to a view people before posting, could make all the difference

5/10

Score: 4

"Needs less and more..."

submission: Indiana Jones Theme

date: May 26, 2008

I say that because there should be more length and depth in the song (yes I know it is very repetitive) but there are a lot of counter melodies and bass chords that could be used creatively (if you have the guts ;) ) But then you need to lessen it a lot with actual number of instruments and chaos. The striking melody is good, love it. But nothing else tickled my fancy. Try to simplify and build (which will help with length too), I give a 2/5 4/10 because I want you to try again and take some time to make an Indiana Jones heavy metal score that is able to knock John Williams into a head bash.

Score: 10

"INCREDIBLE"

submission: Back in the Day [Go West]

date: May 4, 2008

Simply. Incredible. I want more just like this, different themes but same style and talent!

10/10
5/5
Favored Artist and Song
Downloaded.

Score: 1

"OUCH! SCATTERED BRAIN EVERYWHERE"

submission: Mission Impossible Metalized

date: May 3, 2008

Umm, this should not have happened. The guitar falling notes were making me put the song on mute. I hate giving bad reviews, but I have to be honest, you butchered an amazing score with this, well... do I have to call it music?

0/5
1/10